Thinking of buying a BMW X1 or X3? Our in-depth comparison covers design, performance, safety, pricing, and fuel economy to help you make an informed decision.
Design and Features
The BMW X1 and X3 are two popular models in the BMW X series, known for their sleek designs, advanced features, and exceptional performance. When it comes to design and features, both models have their unique strengths and weaknesses. Let’s dive in and explore the similarities and differences between the two.
Exterior Dimensions and Style
The BMW X1 is slightly smaller and more compact than the X3, with a length of 175.4 inches compared to the X3’s 184.5 inches. The X1’s shorter length makes it more agile and easier to maneuver in tight spaces, while the X3’s longer length provides more interior space and cargo room. In terms of style, both models feature BMW’s signature kidney grille, sloping rooflines, and sleek body lines that give them a sporty and dynamic appearance.
Interior Space and Comfort
Inside, the BMW X1 offers a more compact and cozy cabin, with a total passenger space of 101.2 cubic feet. The X3, on the other hand, provides more interior space, with a total passenger space of 110.3 cubic feet. The X1’s smaller size means less legroom and cargo space, but its compact design makes it feel more agile and responsive. The X3’s larger size provides more room for passengers and cargo, making it a better option for families or those who need more space.
Infotainment and Technology Features
Both the BMW X1 and X3 come equipped with advanced infotainment systems, including BMW’s iDrive 7.0 interface, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto. The X1 features a standard 8.8-inch touchscreen display, while the X3 offers a larger 10.25-inch screen. In terms of safety features, both models offer a range of advanced features, including forward collision warning, lane departure warning, and blind spot monitoring. The X3, however, offers more advanced features, such as a 360-degree camera system and a parking assistant.
Performance and Handling
When it comes to the BMW X1 and X3, performance and handling are where these luxury SUVs truly shine. Whether you’re cruising down the highway or navigating winding roads, both models are designed to deliver an exceptional driving experience. But how do they compare in terms of engine options, transmission, and suspension?
Engine Options and Horsepower
The BMW X1 offers two engine options: the sDrive28i and the xDrive28i. The sDrive28i features a 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4 engine that produces 228 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque, while the xDrive28i has the same engine but with all-wheel drive capability. The X3, on the other hand, offers three engine options: the sDrive30i, xDrive30i, and M40i. The sDrive30i and xDrive30i both feature a 2.0-liter turbocharged inline-4 engine that produces 248 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque, while the M40i boasts a 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-6 engine that produces a whopping 382 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque. So, which engine option is right for you? If you’re looking for a more fuel-efficient option, the X1’s sDrive28i might be the way to go. But if you’re looking for sheer power and performance, the X3’s M40i is the clear winner.
Transmission and Drive Modes
Both the X1 and X3 feature an 8-speed automatic transmission that’s designed to provide smooth and seamless shifting. But what sets these SUVs apart is their drive mode capabilities. The X1 offers three drive modes: Eco Pro, Comfort, and Sport, while the X3 offers four drive modes: Eco Pro, Comfort, Sport, and Sport+. These drive modes allow you to customize your driving experience, whether you’re looking to save fuel or unleash your inner racing enthusiast. But here’s the question: do you really need four drive modes? If you’re looking for a more simplified driving experience, the X1’s three drive modes might be the way to go.
Suspension and Steering
When it comes to suspension and steering, both the X1 and X3 are designed to provide a smooth and responsive ride. The X1 features a strut-type front suspension and a multi-link rear suspension, while the X3 features a double-joint spring strut front suspension and a five-link rear suspension. But what does this mean for you? In short, it means that both SUVs are capable of handling rough roads and tight corners with ease. And with features like dynamic damper control and variable sport steering, you can customize your driving experience to suit your mood and driving style. But here’s the question: do you prefer a more athletic, responsive ride or a smoother, more comfortable ride? The answer will depend on your personal preferences and driving habits.
Safety and Reliability
When it comes to safety and reliability, BMW’s X1 and X3 models have a reputation for being some of the most dependable vehicles on the market. But, how do they stack up against each other in these crucial areas? Let’s dive in and find out.
Crash Test Ratings and Safety Features
Both the X1 and X3 have impressive crash test ratings from reputable organizations such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). The X1, for instance, has a perfect 5-star overall safety rating from the NHTSA, while the X3 has a Top Safety Pick+ designation from the IIHS. These impressive ratings are thanks to a plethora of safety features, including:
- Advanced airbag systems
- Electronic stability control
- Anti-lock braking systems
- Lane departure warning and blind spot monitoring
- Forward collision warning and mitigation systems
These safety features are designed to not only protect occupants in the event of an accident but also prevent accidents from occurring in the first place.
Reliability and Warranty Comparison
When it comes to reliability, BMW is known for building vehicles that can withstand the test of time. Both the X1 and X3 have excellent reliability ratings, with the X1 ranked as one of the most reliable luxury SUVs by Consumer Reports. The X3, on the other hand, has a slightly lower reliability rating, but it’s still considered above average in its class.
In terms of warranty, both models come with a 4-year or 50,000-mile basic warranty, as well as a 4-year or 50,000-mile powertrain warranty. However, the X3 has a slightly longer corrosion perforation warranty, covering 12 years and unlimited miles, compared to the X1’s 6-year or 100,000-mile warranty.
Maintenance and Repair Costs
As luxury vehicles, both the X1 and X3 require regular maintenance to keep them running at their best. According to RepairPal, the average annual maintenance cost for the X1 is around $1,200, while the X3 has an average annual maintenance cost of around $1,400. These costs are slightly higher than those of non-luxury SUVs, but they’re still relatively reasonable considering the advanced technology and premium materials used in these vehicles.
It’s worth noting that while the X1 and X3 have similar maintenance costs, the X3 tends to have more frequent oil changes and tire rotations, which can add up over time. However, with proper maintenance, both models can last well over 100,000 miles without major issues.
Pricing and Value
When it comes to making a purchase decision, pricing and value are two crucial factors that can make or break the deal. The BMW X1 and X3 are both luxury vehicles that come with a premium price tag. But are they worth the investment? Let’s dive into the details to find out.
Base Model Prices and Trim Levels
The BMW X1 and X3 are both available in various trim levels, each with its own unique set of features and price point. The X1 is offered in three trim levels: sDrive28i, xDrive28i, and xDrive35i. The sDrive28i is the base model, starting at around $35,000, while the top-of-the-line xDrive35i starts at around $45,000.
The X3, on the other hand, is offered in four trim levels: sDrive30i, xDrive30i, xDrive30i M Sport, and xDrive40i M Sport. The base model sDrive30i starts at around $41,000, while the top-of-the-line xDrive40i M Sport starts at around $55,000.
Feature and Option Pricing
While the base prices of the X1 and X3 may seem steep, the features and options that come with each trim level can quickly add up. For instance, the X1’s optional Convenience Package, which includes features like a panoramic moonroof and universal garage-door opener, costs around $1,500. The X3’s optional Premium Package, which includes features like a heads-up display and gesture control, costs around $2,500.
When it comes to optional features, the X1 and X3 offer a range of choices, from advanced safety features like lane departure warning and blind spot detection to luxury amenities like heated seats and a Harman Kardon premium sound system. Prices for these options vary, but expect to pay around $500 to $2,000 for each feature.
Resale Value and Depreciation
When considering the value of the BMW X1 and X3, it’s essential to think about resale value and depreciation. According to Kelley Blue Book, the X1 retains around 54% of its value after three years, while the X3 retains around 58%. This means that if you purchase a $40,000 X1, you can expect to get around $21,600 back after three years.
Depreciation is another key factor to consider. The X1 and X3 both depreciate at a rate of around 20-25% in the first year, and around 10-15% in the second and third years. This means that the initial purchase price of the vehicle will drop significantly in the first few years of ownership.
However, it’s worth noting that both the X1 and X3 hold their value well compared to other vehicles in their class. This is due in part to their reputation for quality, performance, and luxury amenities.
Fuel Economy and Environment
When it comes to fuel efficiency, environmental impact, and alternative fuel options, the BMW X1 and X3 have some notable differences. As the world becomes increasingly eco-conscious, car buyers are looking for vehicles that not only perform well but also minimize their carbon footprint. So, how do these two BMW models stack up?
MPG Ratings and Fuel Efficiency
The BMW X1 and X3 both offer a range of engine options, each with its own fuel efficiency ratings. The X1’s base model, the sDrive28i, boasts an estimated 24 MPG city and 33 MPG highway. The X3, on the other hand, offers slightly higher ratings, with its base model, the sDrive30i, achieving an estimated 25 MPG city and 34 MPG highway. However, the most fuel-efficient option in the X1 lineup is the xDrive25e, a plug-in hybrid model that achieves an impressive 389 MPGe combined. Meanwhile, the X3’s most fuel-efficient option is the xDrive30e, which achieves an estimated 322 MPGe combined.
But what does this mean for the average driver? If you’re someone who spends a lot of time in heavy city traffic, the X1’s slightly lower city MPG ratings might be a concern. On the other hand, if you’re a long-distance driver, the X3’s higher highway MPG ratings might be more appealing.
Emissions and Environmental Impact
Beyond fuel efficiency, it’s essential to consider the environmental impact of these vehicles. Both the X1 and X3 have made significant strides in reducing emissions, with the X1’s base model emitting 346 g/km of CO2 and the X3’s base model emitting 330 g/km. However, the X1’s plug-in hybrid model takes the lead in terms of environmental sustainability, with an impressive 44 g/km of CO2 emissions. That’s equivalent to the carbon footprint of a small household!
Moreover, BMW has made a commitment to reducing its global carbon footprint by 50% by 2030. As part of this effort, the company is focusing on increasing the use of renewable energy sources, reducing waste and emissions in its production processes, and developing more sustainable vehicle technologies. This means that by choosing a BMW, you’re not only getting a high-performance vehicle but also supporting a company dedicated to reducing its environmental impact.
Alternative Fuel Options
If you’re interested in exploring alternative fuel options, the X1 and X3 both offer some exciting choices. As mentioned earlier, the X1’s xDrive25e is a plug-in hybrid model that combines a traditional gasoline engine with an electric motor. This allows for an all-electric range of up to 25 miles, making it an excellent option for those who want to reduce their reliance on fossil fuels. The X3’s xDrive30e offers similar benefits, with an all-electric range of up to 27 miles. For those who want to take their eco-friendliness to the next level, BMW also offers a range of electric and hybrid models, including the fully electric iX3. With its impressive 273-mile range, this model is perfect for those who want to go the distance without burning a single drop of gasoline.